Backlink Checker vs Manager

Backlink checker vs manager: which one do you need?

The backlink checker vs manager question comes up because the two sound alike but do different jobs. So a backlink checker shows links that a crawler has found to any site. On the other hand, a backlink manager tracks the links you built, with what you agreed, and checks each one on the page. Then most teams that build links end up needing both.

Start freeSee how it works

Free plan: 20 links, 2 clients, 2 projects. Paid plans from $29/mo.

Backlink checker vs manager: tracking built links by hand compared with tracking them in a backlink manager

The confusion

Why backlink checker vs manager gets mixed up

Both show links. They start from different places.

At the same time, First, a backlink checker starts from the web. Instead, Its crawler visits pages, records the links it finds, and builds an index you can search for any domain. That’s why you can also look up a competitor’s links. Ahrefs, for example, runs a crawler called AhrefsBot to build its index.

As a result, a backlink manager, by contrast, starts from your records. So you log each link you build, with the target, anchor, partner and terms, and the manager checks that exact page. So it can’t show you a competitor’s links. However, it can tell you that a link you agreed has switched to nofollow, which an index won’t frame that way.

Different starting point

A checker starts from the web. In addition, a manager starts from your own link records.

Different question

“What links does this site have?” versus “Are the links I built still right?”

Different user

Still, Researchers and auditors versus the people who build and report links.

Side by side

Backlink checker vs manager, job by job

Where each one is the right tool.

  • Research a competitor: checker. A manager only knows your links.
  • Vet a prospect site: checker for metrics, then a manual look before you pitch.
  • Audit a whole profile: checker, because it also includes links you didn’t build.
  • Confirm a placement you built: manager. However, it checks the exact page against what you agreed.
  • Spot a link switched to nofollow: manager. Rather, it compares the current rel value with your record.
  • Report delivery to a client: manager. It knows which links are yours.
Checkers

Backlink checker vs manager: what a checker does well

Breadth. Instead, it sees links you never knew about.

Also, a checker is the only way to see the wider link profile: links from sites you never contacted, competitor links, and new links that appeared on their own. However, its limits come from crawling. A site that blocks the crawler won’t appear, and a page the crawler hasn’t revisited can look lost when it isn’t.

  • Strengths: any domain, a wider profile, and metrics for vetting.
  • Limits: crawl timing, blocked sites, no record of your terms.
Map of SEOENV features in six groups, the backlink manager side of backlink checker vs manager
Managers

Backlink checker vs manager: what a manager does well

Depth. Still, it knows what each of your links should look like.

Meanwhile, a manager holds the link you built, the page it should point to, the anchor and link type you agreed, the partner, and the client it belongs to. Then each check reads the source page directly. In fact, In SEOENV, every logged link gets a status (Active, Lost, Broken or Pending) and a type (Dofollow or Nofollow), checked daily on paid plans (Starter+).

  • Strengths: exact checks, agreed terms, clients, partners, reports.
  • Limits: only covers links you logged.
Four steps of a backlink manager: log the link, it lands here, it gets checked, act on changes

A checker tells you what exists. Meanwhile, a manager tells you what you’re owed.

After that, use the first for research and the second for delivery.

The manager side

What SEOENV covers in the backlink checker vs manager split

SEOENV is a backlink manager. All of these are live today.

Link Tracker

In other words, every link you build, with target, anchor, partner and status.

Read about Link Tracker

Backlink monitoring

So each logged link checked on the page. Paid plans check daily.

Read about Backlink monitoring

Partners

For example, Contacts, terms and deal history for each partner.

Read about Partners

Link Status Report

Rather, Live, lost and nofollow links per client. From Starter.

Read about Link Status Report

Why we wrote this

In other words, people often try SEOENV expecting a backlink index, or try a checker expecting it to know their deals. Neither works. We wrote this to settle the backlink checker vs manager question before anyone wastes a trial.

Using both: backlink checker vs manager is not either-or

Because of that, most teams use a checker for research and audits, and a manager for the links they build. When the two disagree, though, a direct check of the page wins. Our guide to link data sources explains why the numbers rarely match.

So if your built links currently live in a spreadsheet, that’s a manager job done by hand. See the backlink spreadsheet alternative page. For the audit side, our backlink audit guide covers using index data well. And if you are weighing a tool that does a bit of both, our Linkody alternatives page looks at Linkody next to SEOENV, Ahrefs and Semrush.

FAQ

Questions about backlink checker vs manager

Rather, what is the difference between a backlink checker and a backlink manager?

Finally, a checker shows links a crawler has found to any site. In addition, a manager tracks the links you built and checks each one against what you agreed.

Is SEOENV a backlink checker?

No. SEOENV is a backlink manager. Of course, it checks the links you log, not the whole web.

Do I need both?

If you research competitors or audit full profiles, yes. If you only need to track links you build, a manager covers it.

Why does my checker show a link as lost when it is live?

For example, Its crawler may not have revisited the page, or the site may block it. Check the page directly.

Because of that, Can I import links from a checker into SEOENV?

Yes, as long as you can export them to CSV. Import only the links you built.

Track the links you built, not just the ones an index found.

Log your links. SEOENV checks each one on the page.

Start free

Free plan: 20 links, 2 clients, 2 projects. Paid plans from $29/mo.