Broken Backlinks: How to Find Them and What to Fix First

Broken backlinks are the most frustrating kind of link problem, because the hard part is already done. Someone chose to link to you. The link exists. It just doesn't work anymore. At the same time, fixing broken backlinks is often the fastest link win available, and it rarely needs a single outreach email.
The tricky part is also that "broken" means two different things depending on who you ask. So let's split it first.
Key takeaways
- For example, there are two kinds of broken backlinks: links to your pages that no longer exist, and links on source pages that stopped working.
- Even so, links to your own dead pages are the quickest wins, usually fixed with a 301 redirect.
- Meanwhile, links on broken source pages need a conversation with the site owner, or a replacement.
- Check built links on a schedule so you catch breaks while they're still fixable.
Two kinds of broken backlinks
As a result, type 1: the link points to a page on your site that's gone. Rather, someone linked to your old guide, your old pricing page, or a product you retired. That URL now returns a 404. The link still exists on their site. It just leads nowhere.
Type 2: the page holding the link is broken. The source page itself won't load, returns an error, for example, or has been taken down. Your link is technically still in their database, but no visitor or crawler can reach it.
They need very different fixes. Type 1 is mostly in your hands. Type 2 mostly isn't.
Type 1 broken backlinks: links to your dead pages
This is where I'd always start, because you can fix it without asking anyone for anything.
How to find type 1 broken backlinks
- Your backlink tool. Of course, most backlink indexes have a "best by links" or "top pages" view you can filter to pages returning 404. That shows you which dead URLs still attract links.
- Search Console. The Page indexing report lists URLs Google found that return "Not found (404)". Cross-check these against pages that have links.
- Your own memory. Meanwhile, think back to migrations, rebrands and old campaigns. URLs that were popular once are often still linked.
How to fix type 1 broken backlinks
For each dead URL with links pointing at it, ask one question: is there a page now that serves the same purpose?
- Yes: add a 301 redirect from the old URL to the closest equivalent. Google's guide to redirects explains why a permanent server-side redirect is the clearest signal.
- Not quite: consider bringing the content back, even in updated form, if the links are worth it.
- No: let it 404. Redirecting everything to the homepage is tempting, but it tends to confuse users, and Google may treat irrelevant redirects like a soft 404 anyway.
A quick tangent, because I've seen this one too often. During a site migration, someone builds a redirect map from the sitemap. Sounds sensible. But old URLs that weren't in the sitemap, like campaign pages from three years ago, get missed. Those are often the ones with the best links. In addition, always build redirect maps from your backlink data too, not just your sitemap.
See which of your built links are Lost or Broken
Every logged link gets a status, checked daily on paid plans, so breaks show up before your next report.
Type 2 broken backlinks: links on pages that broke
This kind is harder. The problem is on someone else's site.
Common causes of type 2 broken backlinks:
- For example, the site owner deleted or moved the article without a redirect.
- The site went down, expired or changed hands.
- A redesign broke old URLs.
- The page now returns a server error. Google's page on HTTP status codes explains how different errors affect crawling.
What you can do about type 2 broken backlinks
Start by checking whether it's temporary. Servers have bad days. Recheck in a few days before you act.
If it's still broken, it's worth a short, friendly note to the site owner, especially if you built the link through a guest post or a partnership. Many people don't realise their old URLs broke. In fact, something like: "Hi, it looks like the guide we collaborated on at this URL now shows an error. Happy to help if it moved." No guilt, no demands.
If the site has gone for good, mark the link as lost in your records and move on. On the other hand, not every broken backlink can be saved, and that's normal.
Our post on why backlinks disappear covers the related problem where the page is fine but the link itself was removed.
Which broken backlinks to fix first
In other words, you probably can't fix everything in one afternoon. Here's the order I'd use:
| Priority | Situation | Why |
|---|---|---|
| — | — | — |
| 1 | Dead pages on your site with links from relevant sites | Fixable with a redirect, no outreach |
| 2 | Broken source pages for links you built through a partner | You have a relationship, so a quick note often works |
| 3 | Broken source pages on sites you have no contact with | Low odds, but worth one polite email if the site matters |
| 4 | Dead pages with links only from scraper or junk sites | Not worth your time |
Picture this: broken backlinks after a rebrand
Still, picture an in-house SEO who inherits a site after a rebrand. In fact, the old blog lived on a subfolder that no longer exists. Nobody set up redirects for it. A quick look at the backlink tool shows a handful of old posts that still attract links from relevant industry sites.
There's no outreach to do. Rather, a short redirect list, a quick test, and those links point somewhere useful again within the week. It isn't glamorous work. It might be the best hour of the month, though.
Stop finding broken backlinks months later
The real cost of broken backlinks is time. A link that broke last week is easy to fix: the page owner remembers you, the redirect is obvious, and the context is fresh. A link that broke a year ago is a mystery. Dead pages on other sites are an opportunity too; our guide to broken link building shows how to use them.
For the links your team built, for example, checking on a schedule changes that. In SEOENV, every logged link sits in the Link Tracker with a status of Active, Pending, Lost or Broken. On paid plans, links are checked daily, and the Link Status Report shows which ones broke, by client. On the Free plan, you can run Check all whenever you want.
For a wider review that includes broken links, see our backlink audit guide. For ongoing upkeep, our backlink management guide covers the routine.
Frequently asked questions
What are broken backlinks?
They're backlinks that no longer work. Either the link points to a page on your site that returns an error, or the page holding the link has broken or been removed.
How do I fix broken backlinks pointing to my site?
If a relevant replacement page exists, add a 301 redirect from the dead URL to it. If nothing relevant exists, it's fine to let the URL return a 404.
Should I redirect all broken backlinks targets to my homepage?
Usually not. Meanwhile, irrelevant redirects confuse visitors, and Google may treat them like soft 404s. Redirect to the closest matching page instead.
How can I find out when I have broken backlinks?
Meanwhile, log your built links in a backlink manager that checks each source page on a schedule. In SEOENV, for example, paid plans check links daily and show broken ones in the Link Status Report.
Wrap-up and sources
At the same time, broken backlinks reward the teams that look often and act fast. Meanwhile, use these primary sources to check anything in this guide:
- Google Search Central: Redirects and Google Search
- Even so, Google Search Central: HTTP status codes and Google
- Google Search Console Help: Page indexing report
How we wrote this guide. Kritika Das wrote it from day-to-day work logging and checking link exchanges, guest posts and paid placements, for example, and checked each claim against the sources above. We update it when Google changes its guidance.
Catch broken backlinks while they're still easy to fix
Also, log the links you built and see the ones that break, checked daily on paid plans.
Article written by
Kritika Das
Head of Marketing at SEOENV · Forbes-featured content writer
In other words, kritika Das is Head of Marketing at SEOENV and a Forbes-featured content writer. Still, she writes about the operations side of link building: how agencies, freelancers and in-house teams log, check and report the links they build. Her guides come from day-to-day work with link builders and are checked against Google’s own documentation.


Leave A Comment