Turning Competitor Backlinks Into a Shortlist You Can Act On

In practice, competitor backlinks are one of the most common starting points for link prospecting. If a site links to a competitor, it may be open to linking to you too. However, a raw export of a competitor's links is usually long and noisy. That's because many links are irrelevant, low quality or impossible to replicate. So the real work is turning that list into a short set of prospects you can actually act on.
This guide covers how to filter competitor backlinks, group the opportunities and vet each prospect before outreach.
Key takeaways on competitor backlinks
- Competitor backlinks show where links are possible, but raw lists are mostly noise.
- So filter by relevance, link type and how the link was earned.
- Group the remaining links by opportunity type, such as guest posts or resource pages.
- Vet every prospect before outreach and record why it made the list.
Why competitor backlinks are useful
Competitor backlinks show you what's possible in your niche, so they save research time. For example, they reveal which blogs accept guest posts, which resource pages list tools like yours and which publications cover your topic. Because these sites already link to something similar, the case for linking to you is easier to make.
They also help you understand your market. If every competitor has links from the same few industry sites, those sites are probably important to your audience.
Why raw lists need filtering
However, a full export of competitor backlinks often includes thousands of entries, and many come from scraper sites, automated directories or pages that copied content. Meanwhile, others come from spam or link schemes, which Google's link spam policies describe. Also, some are links the competitor earned through relationships or events you can't replicate.
So treat the export as raw material, not a prospect list. The aim is to find the handful of links that are both valuable and achievable. Still need the export? Our guide on how to find backlinks covers the free ways to get one.
Step 1: remove noise from competitor backlinks
First, remove links from sites that are clearly irrelevant or low quality: scraper sites, spammy directories, foreign-language sites with no connection to your market and pages that are just lists of links. As a result, this step usually removes most of the list, which is fine.
Also remove duplicates. Many sites link to competitors from several pages, but you only need the site once.
Step 2: filter competitor backlinks by relevance
Next, keep only sites that are genuinely relevant to your topic and audience. Ask whether the site's readers would find your page useful. If the answer is unclear, the site probably doesn't belong on the shortlist.
Relevance also applies at the page level. For instance, a site might link to a competitor from a page about a topic you don't cover. In that case, the opportunity may not exist for you.
Step 3: understand how each link was earned
Then look at the page and work out why the competitor was linked, for example through a guest post, a resource listing, a mention in an article, a review or a partnership. This tells you what kind of outreach could work, and whether it's realistic.
However, some competitor backlinks can't be replicated, because a link from a conference sponsor page or a leadership interview depends on circumstances you may not share. So set those aside, and focus on opportunities you can genuinely pursue.
Step 4: group competitor backlinks by opportunity
Once filtered, group the remaining competitor backlinks by opportunity type: guest post sites, resource pages, articles that might mention you, directories and so on. Each group needs a different approach, so grouping makes outreach more focused.
For guest posts, our guide on how to find guest post opportunities covers what to look for. Meanwhile, for resource pages, a short, specific note explaining why your page belongs there usually works best.
Step 5: vet each prospect
Before outreach, vet every prospect individually. So check that the site publishes genuine content, has a real audience and doesn't appear to exist mainly to sell links. If you need a checklist, our guide on how to vet a link partner covers the checks.
Then record why each prospect made the shortlist. For example: "Links to two competitors from a tools roundup; our checklist fits the same section." That note makes outreach easier, and it also helps colleagues understand your choices. In addition, our guide to keeping a link prospecting log covers what else to record.
Keep the shortlist short
A good shortlist from competitor backlinks is often a few dozen sites, not hundreds. However, that's a feature, not a problem. Because each prospect is relevant and achievable, your outreach can be personal and specific, which improves replies.
If you need more prospects, repeat the process with another competitor rather than loosening the filters.
Track results once outreach starts
When outreach begins, track each prospect's status: contacted, replied, accepted, live or declined. Then, when links go live, log the page, target, anchor and link type. SEOENV's Link Tracker records those details for every link, and SEOENV checks each one on its page, daily on paid plans (Starter+), with Check all on every plan.
Offer something genuinely useful
Competitor backlinks tell you where links exist, but they don't tell you why you deserve one. So make sure your page is genuinely useful. For example, Google's guidance on helpful content emphasises original, practical information. If your page offers something the competitor's doesn't, such as a clearer checklist or a more recent example, then say so in your outreach.
A quick example
Picture a marketer who exports the backlinks of three competitors and gets several thousand rows. First, they remove scraper sites and duplicates, which leaves a few hundred. Then they filter for relevance and look at how each link was earned, leaving around forty. Once grouped by type, there are fifteen guest post sites, twelve resource pages and a handful of articles. After that, thirty make the shortlist, each with a note on why. As a result, outreach is personal and focused, and replies come back far more often than with a generic list.
Common mistakes with competitor backlinks
The most common mistake is treating the raw export as a prospect list. Another is ignoring how each link was earned, which wastes time on opportunities you can't replicate. A third is skipping vetting because "the competitor has a link from there". Finally, many teams loosen filters to get more prospects, which usually lowers reply rates.
Frequently asked questions about competitor backlinks
Are competitor backlinks good link prospects?
Some are, but filter for relevance, quality and how the link was earned before treating any as prospects.
How many prospects should a shortlist have?
Often a few dozen relevant, achievable sites is better than hundreds of weak ones.
Can I replicate every competitor link?
No, because some depend on relationships, events or circumstances you don't share.
Should I still vet sites that link to competitors?
Yes, because a competitor's link doesn't mean the site is relevant or safe for you.
How do I find competitor backlinks?
Put a competing page, not just the domain, into a backlink index tool and export its referring domains. Most of these tools have a free tier that shows a limited number of rows, which is enough to start. Then run the list through the five steps in this guide.
What is competitor backlink analysis?
It is reviewing who links to competing pages, why they link and whether that reason applies to your page too. The useful output is a short list of prospects, each with a reason to contact them, not a sheet of every link.
How do I check competitor backlinks over time?
Export the same competitor pages every month or quarter and compare the lists. New referring domains show where competitor links are coming from right now, which is usually more useful than their oldest links.
Wrap-up and sources
Use these primary sources to check anything in this guide:
- Google Search Central: Spam policies (link spam)
- Google Search Central: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content
How we wrote this guide. Kritika Das wrote it from day-to-day work logging and checking link exchanges, guest posts and paid placements, and checked each claim against the sources above. We update it when Google changes its guidance.
Track every link you win from your shortlist
SEOENV logs each new link with its page, target and anchor, then checks it on a schedule.
Article written by
Kritika Das
Head of Marketing at SEOENV · Forbes-featured content writer
Kritika Das is Head of Marketing at SEOENV and a Forbes-featured content writer. She writes about the operations side of link building: how agencies, freelancers and in-house teams log, check and report the links they build. Her guides come from day-to-day work with link builders and are checked against Google’s own documentation.


Leave A Comment