Guest Post Follow Up: When and How to Chase an Editor

A guest post follow up is a short, polite message to an editor who hasn't replied yet. Editors are busy, so pitches get buried, and a single reminder often brings a response. However, too many reminders, or ones sent too soon, can close the door. So timing and tone matter as much as the message itself.
This guide covers when to send a guest post follow up after a pitch, after a draft and after publication, with example wording for each.
Key takeaways on guest post follow up
- A guest post follow up should be short, polite and sent once at each stage.
- Allow a reasonable gap after the pitch before following up.
- Follow up on drafts and live links too, not just pitches.
- Record every follow-up so you never chase the same editor twice by mistake.
Why a guest post follow up works
Most editors don't ignore pitches on purpose. Instead, pitches slip down a busy inbox, or the editor means to reply and forgets. A follow-up simply brings yours back to the top. Since it shows you're organised and genuinely interested, it can also improve your chances, as long as it's brief.
When to follow up after a pitch
Allow a reasonable gap before you follow up, because editors need time to read and decide. If the site's guidelines mention a response time, wait at least that long. Otherwise, a gap of around a week or two is common practice, although nothing is fixed.
Then send one guest post follow up. If there's still no reply after another similar gap, it's usually best to move on and pitch the idea elsewhere. Sending a third or fourth message rarely helps, and it may make the editor less likely to work with you later.
What to write in a guest post follow up
Keep it short. Reply to your original email, so the editor can see the pitch without searching, and add two or three lines. For example:
"Hi [name], just following up on the article idea I sent last week about [topic]. I'd be happy to adjust the angle if it's not quite right for your readers. Thanks for considering it."
That's enough. Avoid guilt ("I've emailed twice now"), pressure ("I need an answer by Friday") or long repeats of the pitch. If you want to add value, include one new detail, such as a fresh example, since it gives the editor a reason to look again.
Following up on an accepted draft
Sometimes the editor accepts the idea, you send the draft and then nothing happens. In that case, a guest post follow up is just as appropriate. Wait for the timeframe the editor mentioned, or a reasonable gap if they didn't, then ask briefly whether the draft needs anything else.
For example: "Hi [name], I wanted to check whether the draft I sent on [date] needs any changes. Happy to revise if anything isn't quite right." Again, keep it short, and don't ask for a publication date unless they've offered one.
Following up after publication
Follow-ups aren't only for pitches. Once the post is live, check that the link is present, points at the agreed page and carries the expected rel value. Google's guide to qualifying outbound links explains those values. If something is missing or wrong, then a polite guest post follow up is the right step.
Thank the editor first, and then mention the issue factually. For example: "Thanks for publishing the article. I noticed the link to our guide seems to be missing from the second section. Would you be able to add it back when you have a moment?" Our guide on what to check after a guest post goes live covers the details to confirm.
Following up months later
Links can disappear long after publication, for example during a redesign. So if a routine check shows a guest post link has gone, a follow-up is still reasonable, even a year later. Keep it as polite as the first message, and include the article URL and the original link, because the editor may not remember the post.
However, if the editor has moved on, or the site has changed hands, the reply may never come. In that case, record the outcome and decide whether the link is worth pursuing further.
Record every guest post follow up
Follow-ups are easy to lose track of, especially across many sites. If you don't record them, you might chase the same editor twice in one week, or forget to chase at all. So log the date of each pitch, each follow-up and each reply, along with the stage the article was at.
SEOENV's Guest Posts workspace tracks each article from Pitched to Published, so you can see which pitches are waiting and for how long. Then, once the article is live, SEOENV checks its link on the page, daily on paid plans (Starter+), with Check all on every plan. If the link turns Lost or Broken, you'll know it's time for a follow-up.
Match the tone to the stage
The tone of a guest post follow up should match where the article is. After a pitch, keep it light, because the editor owes you nothing yet. After an accepted draft, you can be a little more direct, since you've both agreed to work together. Meanwhile, after publication, lead with thanks, because the editor has already done you a favour. In every case, though, stay friendly and brief, as editors remember how contributors made them feel.
A quick example
Picture a marketer with ten pitches out. Without records, they lose track and send a second guest post follow up to an editor who had already replied. The editor is polite but less enthusiastic. Afterwards, the marketer logs every pitch and follow-up date, so each editor gets exactly one reminder at the right time. As a result, replies come more often, and no editor is chased twice by mistake.
Common guest post follow up mistakes
The most common mistake is following up too soon, sometimes within a day or two. Another is sending a long follow-up that repeats the whole pitch. A third is following up too many times. Finally, many people forget to follow up on drafts and live links at all, even though those follow-ups often matter more than the first one.
Frequently asked questions about guest post follow up
When should I send a guest post follow up?
After a reasonable gap, often around a week or two, or longer if the site's guidelines say so.
How many times should I follow up?
Usually once, and then move on if there's still no reply after another similar gap.
What should a follow-up email say?
Two or three polite lines that reference the original pitch, with an offer to adjust the idea.
Should I follow up if my guest post link disappears?
Yes. Thank the editor, give the article URL and the original link, and ask politely whether it can be restored.
Wrap-up and sources
Use these primary sources to check anything in this guide:
- Google Search Central: Qualify your outbound links
- Google Search Central: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content
How we wrote this guide. Kritika Das wrote it from day-to-day work logging and checking link exchanges, guest posts and paid placements, and checked each claim against the sources above. We update it when Google changes its guidance.
Know when to follow up
SEOENV tracks each guest post from Pitched to Published, then checks the link so you can see when something changes.
Article written by
Kritika Das
Head of Marketing at SEOENV · Forbes-featured content writer
Kritika Das is Head of Marketing at SEOENV and a Forbes-featured content writer. She writes about the operations side of link building: how agencies, freelancers and in-house teams log, check and report the links they build. Her guides come from day-to-day work with link builders and are checked against Google’s own documentation.


Leave A Comment