Link BuildingPublished · 6 min read

How to Track Backlinks: Four Methods Compared Honestly

By Kritika Das · Head of Marketing at SEOENV
Illustration of four ways to track backlinks, from search console to a backlink manager

Also, ask five SEOs how they track backlinks and you'll get five setups. One swears by Search Console. Another lives in Ahrefs. A third has a spreadsheet so detailed it has its own colour key. They're all right, sort of, because they're answering different questions.

That's the core idea of this post. When you track backlinks, you're really asking one of two things:

  1. What links point to my site? This is discovery.
  2. Are the links we built still live and still the way we agreed? This is verification.

For example, most frustration with backlink tracking comes from using a discovery tool to do a verification job, or the other way round. Let's look at four methods and what each is actually good for.

Key takeaways

  • There are two questions: which links exist, and are the links we built still working.
  • Instead, search Console and backlink indexes answer the first question well.
  • Spreadsheets and backlink managers answer the second, because they start from your own records.
  • Even so, most teams need one of each, not four tools doing the same job.

Method 1 to track backlinks: Google Search Console

Even so, search Console is free and comes straight from Google. Its Links report shows top linking sites, top linked pages and top linking text for your property. Our step-by-step guide on how to find backlinks shows how to combine it with free index tools.

What it's good at: a broad, trustworthy view of who links to you, from the search engine whose opinion matters most.

What it misses: it's a sample, not a complete list, and it isn't built for checking individual links. You can't easily answer "is our guest post on site X still dofollow?" There's also no concept of a client, a campaign or a deal.

Use it for: a monthly sanity check of your overall link profile.

Rather, these tools crawl the web and build their own link databases. You can also see new and lost links, referring domains, anchors and much more, for your site and your competitors'.

What it's good at: discovery at scale, competitor research, and spotting broad trends.

What it misses: a crawler sees what it crawls, when it crawls it. A link you built last week might not appear for a while. Of course, a link that was removed might show as lost on a delay. At the same time, and these tools don't know which links your team built, what you agreed with the editor, or which client a link belongs to.

Use it for: research and a second opinion. It's an index, not a ledger.

Method 3 to track backlinks: the spreadsheet

Ah, the spreadsheet. Nearly every link builder has one. It starts with five columns and ends with thirty.

What it's good at: recording what you built. Of course, source page, target URL, anchor, date, partner, client, notes. It's flexible and free. If you need a starting point, our link building spreadsheet template is a solid one.

What it misses: a spreadsheet doesn't check anything. If a partner removes your link, the row still says "live". In fact, someone has to open each page by hand, which means it happens rarely or not at all. Even so, and once three people work from copies, nobody knows which version is true.

Use it for: small volumes, early on, or as an export format.

Move from a sheet that records to a tool that checks

Import your links with CSV column mapping and see each one's live status.

Start free

A backlink manager starts from your records, like a spreadsheet, and then visits each source page to confirm the link is there. That's the key difference from a backlink index. It doesn't try to find every link on the web. It checks the ones you tell it about.

What it's good at: verification. Is the link still on the page? Does it still point to the right URL? Has it turned nofollow or sponsored (Google explains these values in its page on qualifying outbound links)? Which client and deal does it belong to?

What it misses: links you never logged. It's not a discovery tool, so pair it with Search Console or an index. Tools such as Linkody combine discovery with monitoring; our Linkody alternatives page compares them fairly.

Use it for: anything you've built, exchanged, placed or listed, especially if you report to clients.

Side by side: four ways to track backlinks

Method Finds new links Confirms your built links Knows client and deal Cost
— — — — —
Search Console Yes, a sample No No Free
Backlink index Yes, at scale Partly, on its crawl schedule No Paid
Spreadsheet No Only by hand Yes, if you type it Free
Backlink manager No Yes Yes Free tier to paid

The setup I’d recommend to track backlinks

Of course, for most teams that track backlinks for clients, I'd keep it simple: one discovery tool and one verification tool.

  • Use Search Console (and an index if you already pay for one) to see the wider profile.
  • Use a backlink manager for every link your team built, for example, swapped or placed.

Actually, picture an agency with 40 guest posts across 12 clients. The index shows the overall trend. The backlink manager tells the account lead, before the monthly report, which three guest posts lost their link and which one turned nofollow. Those are also different jobs, and trying to do both in one tool usually means one gets done badly.

On the other hand, whatever tool you use to track backlinks, these fields earn their place. Skip one and you'll feel it at report time:

  • source page URL and target URL
  • anchor text
  • link type (dofollow or nofollow) at the last check
  • status: active, pending, lost or broken
  • client and project
  • Because of that, where it came from: guest post, exchange, placement or listing
  • date added and date last checked

If you want to see how those fields feed reporting, our post on link building KPIs is a good companion.

How SEOENV helps you track backlinks

SEOENV is a backlink manager. Every link you log, whether it came from a guest post, an exchange, a placement or a directory listing, lands in the Link Tracker with its status (Active, Pending, Lost or Broken) and type (Dofollow, Nofollow or Unknown), read from the rel attribute on the live page. On paid plans, links are checked daily and the results show in the Link Status Report. On the Free plan, you can run Check all whenever you like. You can bring links in through CSV import with column mapping and export them any time.

For the broader picture of managing links once they're tracked, read our backlink management guide. And if links are already going missing, start with why backlinks disappear.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best free way to track backlinks?

Google Search Console's Links report is the best free view of who links to you. For checking links you built, a backlink manager's free plan or a well-kept spreadsheet works for small volumes.

Can Ahrefs or Semrush track backlinks I built?

Meanwhile, they show links their crawlers find, which often includes yours. They don't know which links you built or what you agreed, and changes can appear with a delay.

How often should I track backlinks I built?

Links you built should be checked often, ideally daily or weekly, because removals and rel changes happen without notice. Wider profile reviews can be monthly.

What’s the difference when you track backlinks with an index vs a manager?

An index crawls the web to discover links. In other words, a backlink manager starts from your own records and checks each logged link on its source page.

What is the simplest way to start tracking backlinks?

List every link you build in one place with the source page, target, anchor and date, then recheck each source page on a schedule. A spreadsheet is fine at first; a tracker that does the rechecking saves the monthly chore.

Can I offer white label backlink tracking to clients?

Yes. On the Growth plan, SEOENV reports carry your own logo and colours, and on Enterprise they can sit on your own domain.

Should I track back links I did not build?

Find them through the Links report in Google Search Console or an index tool, but there is less reason to watch them closely, since you never agreed terms for them.

Wrap-up and sources

However you track backlinks, the point is the same: know what you built, and know if it's still there. Also, use these primary sources to check anything in this guide:

How we wrote this guide. Kritika Das wrote it from day-to-day work logging and checking link exchanges, guest posts and paid placements, for example, and checked each claim against the sources above. We update it when Google changes its guidance.

Track backlinks you built, not just the ones a crawler finds

Also, log every link, get daily checks on paid plans and see what changed in the Link Status Report.

Start free

Article written by

Kritika Das

Head of Marketing at SEOENV · Forbes-featured content writer

Meanwhile, kritika Das is Head of Marketing at SEOENV and a Forbes-featured content writer. Still, she writes about the operations side of link building: how agencies, freelancers and in-house teams log, check and report the links they build. Her guides come from day-to-day work with link builders and are checked against Google’s own documentation.

More posts by Kritika