Semrush Lost Backlinks: Why a Live Link Can Show as Lost (Ahrefs Too)

It's a familiar Monday. A client forwards a screenshot of their Semrush lost backlinks report, with a worried note: "We lost twelve links last week. What happened?" You open the first one. The link is right there on the page, exactly where it was. You open the second. Also there.
So what's going on? Meanwhile, Semrush lost backlinks reports, and Ahrefs' lost links view, aren't wrong exactly. Rather, they're answering a different question from the one your client is asking. Once you understand that difference, for example, those Monday emails get a lot easier.
Key takeaways
- Index tools like Semrush and Ahrefs report what their crawlers last saw, not a live check from backlink monitoring software.
- On the other hand, a "lost" link can mean the page changed, redirected or wasn't recrawled, not that the link was removed.
- Always confirm on the live page before telling a client or emailing a partner.
- Also, use the index for discovery and a direct page check for the links you built.
What Semrush lost backlinks reports actually tell you
Semrush, Ahrefs, Moz and similar tools run their own crawlers. On the other hand, they visit pages across the web, record the links they find, and store them in a database. When a crawler revisits a page and doesn't find a link it saw before, or can't process the page the way it did last time, the tool may mark that link as lost.
That's the key: "lost" means "not found on our latest crawl, in the way we found it before". It doesn't mean "someone deleted it". Of course, the crawler's view and the live page can differ for lots of ordinary reasons. That's also why Semrush lost backlinks and Ahrefs lost links rarely match each other exactly: different crawlers, different schedules.
Seven reasons Semrush lost backlinks can still be live
1. The page wasn't recrawled cleanly. In addition, a timeout, a server hiccup or a blocked request, and the tool may record the page as changed.
2. The URL changed format. The page moved from http to https, added or dropped www, or picked up a trailing slash. Your link is still there, on what the tool sees as a different URL.
3. The page redirected. The article moved and the old URL now redirects. Instead, the tool may log the old link as lost and the new one as new, sometimes on different days. Google's guide to redirects explains how moves work.
4. The page became non-canonical. The publisher added a canonical tag pointing elsewhere. Some tools then stop counting links on the non-canonical version. Google's page on consolidating duplicate URLs covers how canonicals work.
5. The page went noindex. In other words, some tools treat links on pages that have dropped out of their index differently.
6. The link moved within the page. In fact, a redesign moved the article body into a different template, or the link now loads with JavaScript. A crawler that doesn't render scripts may miss it.
7. The link really was removed. It happens, of course. But it's only one of seven possibilities.
Ahrefs often shows a reason next to a lost link, for example, and Semrush has a view of new and lost links over time. Both help you sort the list. Neither replaces opening the page.
Confirm what's really live, not what a crawler last saw
Instead, SEOENV checks each logged link on its source page and shows Active, Lost or Broken, plus the link type.
How to check Semrush lost backlinks before you panic
When the Semrush lost backlinks list lands in your inbox, work through it in this order:
- Open the source page. Use a normal browser, not a cached copy.
- Find your link. Use the browser's find tool and search for your domain.
- Check the URL format. Is the page now on a slightly different URL?
- Check for a redirect. Did the address bar change when the page loaded?
- Inspect the link. Right-click, Inspect, and read the
relvalue. Has it changed to nofollow or sponsored? - Check the page's head. Look for a canonical tag pointing elsewhere or a
noindextag.
Most of the time you'll find one of the first six reasons above. Note it, and move on.
What to tell the client about Semrush lost backlinks
In fact, clients who see Semrush lost backlinks in a dashboard don't need a lecture on crawlers. They need a clear, short answer. Something like:
We checked all twelve. Nine are still live, with the same anchor and type. Two moved to new URLs on the same sites and are still in place. One was removed during a redesign, and we've asked the editor about it.
That answer builds trust, because it's specific. It also shows the difference between your records and a third-party index. If you report links regularly, it helps to base the report on direct checks rather than index data. Our link building report template has columns for that.
A scenario with Semrush lost backlinks that are still live
Picture an in-house SEO preparing a quarterly review. For example, the backlink tool shows a sharp drop in referring domains for one month. Leadership asks whether something broke.
Even so, on closer inspection, a large share of those "lost" links came from one publisher that moved its blog to a new subfolder. Every page redirected. The links still exist on the new URLs, and the tool picks them up again over the following weeks. In addition, the drop was a crawler catching up with a migration, not a real loss.
Without a direct check, for example, that SEO might have spent a week chasing a problem that didn't exist.
Use each tool when you read Semrush lost backlinks
I'm not saying ignore Semrush lost backlinks reports, or your index tool in general. Meanwhile, it's excellent for discovery: new links you didn't know about, competitor research, broad trends. Google Search Console's Links report adds Google's own view for free.
But for the links your team built, through guest posts, exchanges and placements, a direct page check is the reliable source. That's the split I'd suggest: index tools for the wider profile, for example, direct checks for your own work. Our backlink management guide explains how the two fit together.
Where SEOENV fits next to Semrush lost backlinks reports
SEOENV doesn't crawl the web like Semrush or Ahrefs. It checks the links you've logged. Each one sits in the Link Tracker with a status (Active, Pending, Lost or Broken) and a type (Dofollow, Nofollow or Unknown), read from the live source page. On paid plans, links are checked daily and the Link Status Report shows what changed, per client. On the Free plan, you can run Check all whenever a scary report turns up.
When a link really is gone, our guide to why backlinks disappear covers the next steps.
Frequently asked questions
Why does Semrush lost backlinks show links that are still live?
Semrush lost backlinks are based on what its crawler last found. A page that redirected, changed URL format, became non-canonical or wasn't recrawled cleanly can show a link as lost even though it's still on the live page.
Are Ahrefs reports more accurate than Semrush lost backlinks?
Both are index tools with their own crawlers and schedules. Each can show links as lost that are still live. Confirm important links on the page itself.
How do I confirm Semrush lost backlinks are really lost?
Open the source page in a browser, search for your domain, check for redirects and URL changes, and inspect the link's rel value and the page's canonical and noindex tags.
Should I report Semrush lost backlinks data to clients raw?
Use it for trends and discovery, but base reports on links you've checked directly. That avoids false alarms from crawler timing.
Wrap-up and sources
Treat Semrush lost backlinks as a lead, not a verdict. Then go look at the page. Use these primary sources to check anything in this guide:
- Google Search Console Help: Links report
- Google Search Central: Consolidate duplicate URLs
- Google Search Central: Redirects and Google Search
How we wrote this guide. Still, kritika Das wrote it from day-to-day work logging and checking link exchanges, guest posts and paid placements, and checked each claim against the sources above. We update it when Google changes its guidance.
Answer "did we lose links?" in minutes
Also, log the links you built and check each one on the live page, by client.
Article written by
Kritika Das
Head of Marketing at SEOENV · Forbes-featured content writer
Even so, kritika Das is Head of Marketing at SEOENV and a Forbes-featured content writer. For example, she writes about the operations side of link building: how agencies, freelancers and in-house teams log, check and report the links they build. Her guides come from day-to-day work with link builders and are checked against Google’s own documentation.


Leave A Comment