Partner Scorecard

Link partner scorecard: rate partners on what they deliver

A partner scorecard gives you a fair way to compare the people you place links with. Instead of a gut feeling, you score each partner on what your records show: links still live, links followed as agreed, relevance, response time and whether they kept their terms. Download the template and fill it in each quarter.

Start freeGet the template

Free to download, no sign-up. Want the numbers filled in from real checks? Free plan: 20 links, 2 clients, 2 projects. Paid plans from $29/mo.

Sample partner record with contact, deal terms, linked deals and notes, the source data for a partner scorecard

Why score

Why a partner scorecard beats gut feeling

So Memory favours the friendly partners, not the reliable ones.

After that, most teams have a sense of which partners are good. However, that sense comes from recent emails, not from what happened to the links. A partner who replies quickly can still lose links in every redesign. On the other hand, a quiet partner may have the best record you’ve got.

Instead, picture a team deciding where to place next quarter’s links. They fill in the partner scorecard from their link records and find that one favourite partner has lost half its links, while a partner they rarely think about has kept every one. The decision makes itself.

Recency bias

The last email shapes the opinion, not the last year.

No shared view

Each builder rates partners differently.

Hard conversations

Meanwhile, Without numbers, raising a problem feels personal.

The scores

What each partner scorecard column measures

Then keep it to a few columns you can fill from records.

  • Links placed: how many links the partner placed in the last twelve months.
  • Still live: how many of those are live today.
  • Followed as agreed: how many still match the agreed link type. Google explains the rel values that change this.
  • Relevance (1-3): how well the partner’s sites fit your clients.
  • Response time (1-3): how quickly they reply when something needs fixing.
  • Kept terms (1-3): whether they stuck to what you agreed.
Filling it in

Fill in the partner scorecard from your link records

So the first three columns are counts, not opinions.

Start with the counts, because they’re the least arguable. Filter your link list by partner, then count links placed, links still live, and links still followed as agreed. Next, add the three 1 to 3 scores. Finally, write one line of notes explaining anything unusual.

  • Counts first: placed, live, followed.
  • Then scores: relevance, response, terms.
  • Then notes: one line per partner.
Four steps of Partners in SEOENV that feed a partner scorecard: add the partner, record terms, link the deals, review history
Using it

What to do with partner scorecard results

Scores are for decisions, not for filing.

Give more work to partners at the top. Have a direct, friendly conversation with partners at the bottom, using the counts rather than impressions. Then review the partner scorecard again next quarter and see whether anything changed.

  • Top scores: first choice for new placements.
  • Middle: keep, but watch.
  • Bottom: talk, then decide.
Link Status Report summary with Active, Pending, Broken and Lost counts used to fill in a partner scorecard

The best partner is the one whose links are still there.

In other words, Score on outcomes, and the right partners rise to the top.

What helps

SEOENV features that fill in the scorecard

All of these are live in the app today.

Partners

Because of that, Contacts, terms, notes and deal history per partner.

Read about Partners

Link Tracker

On the other hand, every link tied to the partner who placed it.

Read about Link Tracker

Link Status Report

Live, lost and nofollow counts per client. From Starter.

Read about Link Status Report

CSV export

In other words, Export links by partner to fill in the counts.

Read about CSV export

Why we made this

Partner decisions were always the hardest calls in link work, because they felt personal. Also, a simple partner scorecard built on link records turns them into a conversation about numbers.

Partner scorecard tips

Keep the scorecard short, and keep the definitions written at the top so everyone scores the same way. For the counts, use links still live and followed as agreed, rather than any third-party authority score. Our guide to link survival rate shows how to compare partners over time.

Use the scorecard alongside your vetting process, not instead of it. For new partners, see how to vet a link partner. For swap partners, the link swap requests page covers screening requests before you agree.

FAQ

Questions about the partner scorecard

What is a link partner scorecard?

A simple table that rates each partner on what their links show: how many are still live, still followed, relevant, and whether the partner kept their terms.

How often should I update it?

Once a quarter is usually enough.

Should I share scores with partners?

Share the counts if you raise a problem. Keep the scores internal.

Is the template free?

Yes. In addition, Download the CSV and open it in any spreadsheet app.

Can SEOENV fill in the counts?

SEOENV ties each link to a partner and checks it, so you can filter or export by partner and count live and followed links.

Score partners on links that are still live.

Log links against each partner. SEOENV checks them so the counts are real.

Start free

Free plan: 20 links, 2 clients, 2 projects. Paid plans from $29/mo.