Fixing Over-Optimised Anchors Without Losing the Links

Over-optimised anchors rarely arrive all at once. At the same time, they build up over a few campaigns where every brief asked for the same keyword. By the time someone notices, a money page has a stack of exact-match links and the team is unsure whether to panic, delete things or do nothing.
As a result, the good news is that most cases don't need anything drastic. For example, this guide walks through how to confirm you have a problem, how to decide what to do with each link, and how to stop it happening again.
Key takeaways on over-optimised anchors
- For example, over-optimised anchors are usually a per-page problem, not a sitewide one.
- For each link, decide whether to change it, dilute it or leave it.
- In fact, asking an editor to change an anchor works best on links you built through a real relationship.
- Disavowing good links to fix an anchor mix usually does more harm than good.
First, confirm you really have over-optimised anchors
Before you touch a single link, check the pattern is real. A few exact-match links to a page is normal. People do sometimes link with the keyword, because it describes the page.
Look at anchor text per page rather than sitewide. Also, group your built links by target URL and classify each anchor as branded, URL, exact match, partial match, generic or other. Our free anchor text checker does this from a pasted list.
You probably have over-optimised anchors on a page if exact match is the largest group for that target, or if the same exact phrase repeats across many links. There's no official threshold. Google's spam policies talk about optimised anchor text in articles and guest posts distributed on other sites, not about a percentage. So judge by pattern and by how the links were built.
What this looks like in practice
Actually, picture an agency running a year-long campaign for a client's main service page. Every guest post brief named the same phrase, because it was the phrase the client wanted to rank for. Editors used it as supplied. Twelve months later, the page's anchor text distribution is lopsided: most links use one exact match anchor text, and almost none use the brand.
Nobody did anything unusual. Each link, on its own, was a reasonable request. For example, the problem came from repeating the same request without anyone looking at the total. Rather, that's why the fix below focuses as much on the brief as on the existing links.
Why over-optimised anchors happen
Understanding the cause stops you repeating it.
- Briefs that always name the same anchor. The most common reason by far in our experience.
- Editors who use what you send. If you supply an exact anchor, most hosts will use it.
- Campaigns focused on one page. Also, months of effort on a single money page concentrate anchors quickly.
- No per-page reporting. A sitewide mix can look healthy while one page leans hard on exact match.
Fixing over-optimised anchors: change, dilute or leave
Because of that, for each exact-match link to a flagged page, pick one of three options.
Change the anchor
After that, ask the editor to adjust the anchor to something branded or descriptive. In addition, this works best for links you placed through a real relationship, where the editor remembers you and the request is easy.
Finally, keep the email short: "Could we change the link text in paragraph two from [exact phrase] to [brand name]? Meanwhile, happy for you to pick wording that fits the sentence." Most editors won't mind, and some won't reply. Either outcome is fine.
Dilute the mix
Finally, build the next links to that page with branded, URL and descriptive anchors. Rather, over time the exact-match share falls without touching existing links. Instead, this is the lowest-risk option and the one we use most.
Leave it alone
Some exact-match links are perfectly natural: a relevant editorial mention on a respected site, using the phrase because it describes the page. Leave those. Changing them risks the link itself.
What not to do about over-optimised anchors
A few reactions cause more damage than the original problem.
Don't mass-remove good links. At the same time, asking every host to delete links loses value you'll struggle to replace.
Don't disavow links just to fix a ratio. Google's disavow tool is meant for unnatural links you can't get removed, typically after a manual action. Also, disavowing relevant links from good sites to rebalance anchors usually hurts. Our guide on how to disavow backlinks covers when it's appropriate.
Don't swing to the other extreme. In addition, replacing every anchor with "click here" isn't natural either. Google's guidance on anchor text asks for anchors that describe the linked page.
A simple order of work
If you're short on time, this sequence handles most cases.
- Pause exact-match requests to the flagged page today.
- List the exact-match links to that page, with the partner for each.
- Mark which ones to leave. Instead, natural editorial mentions on strong sites stay as they are.
- Ask a handful of friendly partners to change their anchor to branded or descriptive text.
- Plan the next placements with branded, URL and descriptive anchors only.
- Recheck the per-page mix after the next round, so you can see whether it moved.
In addition, most teams find steps one and five do the heavy lifting. On the other hand, the emails in step four are a bonus, not the core of the fix.
Preventing over-optimised anchors next time
Prevention lives in the brief. Give each target page a short list of acceptable anchors, including branded and descriptive options, and rotate through them. Track the anchor of every link as you log it, so the per-page view is always current. If you use SEOENV, the Link Tracker records the anchor with each link, and the Anchor Text Heatmap shows the mix per target.
Finally, review the per-page mix before every new campaign, not after. It takes minutes and saves the clean-up entirely. Our anchor text ratio guide explains why fixed percentages mislead.
Frequently asked questions about over-optimised anchors
How do I fix over-optimised anchors?
Confirm the pattern per page, then for each exact-match link decide whether to change it, dilute it with new varied anchors, or leave it.
Should I disavow links with over-optimised anchors?
Usually not. The disavow tool is for unnatural links you can't remove. At the same time, disavowing good links to fix a ratio tends to lose value.
How long does it take to fix over-optimised anchors?
Diluting the mix takes as long as your next few rounds of placements. At the same time, changing existing anchors depends on how quickly editors reply.
Can I ask an editor to change an anchor?
Yes, politely and specifically. It works best where you have an existing relationship. Accept a no gracefully.
Wrap-up and sources
Finally, use these primary sources to check anything in this guide:
- Google Search Central: Spam policies (link spam)
- As a result, Google Search Central: Link best practices (anchor text)
- Google Search Console Help: Disavow links to your site
How we wrote this guide. Kritika Das wrote it from day-to-day work logging and checking link exchanges, guest posts and paid placements, for example, and checked each claim against the sources above. We update it when Google changes its guidance.
Spot over-optimised targets before the next campaign
SEOENV's Anchor Text Heatmap groups anchors by type and flags over-optimised targets (Growth plan).
Article written by
Kritika Das
Head of Marketing at SEOENV · Forbes-featured content writer
Kritika Das is also Head of Marketing at SEOENV and a Forbes-featured content writer. Still, she writes about the operations side of link building: how agencies, freelancers and in-house teams log, check and report the links they build. Her guides come from day-to-day work with link builders and are checked against Google’s own documentation.


Leave A Comment