Link BuildingPublished · 5 min read

Link Tracking for Ahrefs Users: What the Index Can and Can't Do

By Kritika Das · Head of Marketing at SEOENV
Illustration for Ahrefs users comparing a crawler-based backlink index with a record of the links a team built

For example, this guide is for Ahrefs users who want to understand where the index helps, where it leaves gaps, and how to fill them without dropping the tool.

As a result, Ahrefs users who build links often assume the tool covers everything they need. In fact, for research, audits and prospecting, it covers a lot. But link building also involves deals: a partner agreed to place a followed link, on a certain page, with a certain anchor. An index built by a crawler can't know any of that.

Key takeaways on Ahrefs users

  • On the other hand, Ahrefs users get a strong view of links its crawler has found across the web.
  • Instead, an index can't know what you agreed with a partner, or which links you built.
  • For example, sites that block AhrefsBot and pages it hasn't revisited create gaps.
  • Also, track built links in your own records and use Ahrefs for research and audits.

What Ahrefs users get from the index

Because of that, Ahrefs builds its data by crawling the web with its own bot, AhrefsBot. Rather, it records the links it finds and makes them searchable for any domain. That makes it good at jobs no SEOENV’s backlink tracker can do:

  • Researching competitors. You can see links pointing to sites you don't own.
  • Vetting prospects. Metrics such as Domain Rating give a quick first filter.
  • Auditing a whole profile. Meanwhile, the index includes links you never built, which matters for clean-up work.
  • Spotting new links. As a result, links you didn't know about show up as the crawler finds them.

None of that changes. Ahrefs users should keep using it for these jobs.

Where the index leaves gaps for Ahrefs users

At the same time, the gaps come from how any crawler-based index works, not from a flaw in one tool.

It only sees what its crawler reaches

Ahrefs says AhrefsBot obeys robots.txt. So a site that blocks it won't appear in the index, even if it links to you. New pages and pages buried deep in a site also take time to be found.

It can't know what you agreed

An index knows that a link exists. But it doesn't know that you agreed a followed link with a specific anchor to a specific page. So if a partner changes the anchor or adds nofollow, the index records the new state without flagging that it breaks your deal.

On the other hand, for an agency, "links built for this client this quarter" is a different list from "all links to this domain". The index shows the second. Your reports need the first.

Timing

Still, a link that drops out of an export may simply not have been revisited. A link that's gone may still show until the crawler returns. Either way, the index reflects the crawler's last visit, not today.

How Ahrefs users can fill the gaps

The fix is a second record that starts from your side: the links you built, for example, with what you agreed. Then check each one against the live page.

  1. Log every link you build. At the same time, source page, target, anchor, agreed link type, partner and client.
  2. Check each link on the page. Not in an index, but by reading the source page itself.
  3. Compare against what you agreed. A link that is live but nofollow when you agreed followed is a problem only your records can spot. Google explains the rel values in its guide to qualifying outbound links.
  4. Report from your records. After that, use the index for context, not for delivery numbers.

A worked example for Ahrefs users

Actually, picture an agency that reports monthly using the new and lost links from its index. One month, the lost list shows eight links. The team opens each page. Five links are still there; the crawler hadn't revisited. Two were genuinely removed. One is live but now nofollow, which the index showed as a normal link with a nofollow tag, with no hint that it broke an agreement.

With their own records checked against the live pages, the team would have known about the three real issues sooner, for example, and wouldn't have spent time on the five false alarms. The index was still useful: it surfaced two new links they hadn't built, which went into the client's wider profile notes.

On the other hand, think of them as two lists that answer different questions.

Question Better source
— —
Which links does this competitor have? Ahrefs
Is this prospect worth pitching? Ahrefs, plus a manual look
Are the links we built still live? Your link tracker
Are they still followed as agreed? Your link tracker
What did we deliver this month? Your link tracker
What else links to the client? Ahrefs

Our guide to link data sources goes through why the numbers rarely match, and the backlink checker vs manager comparison explains the two types of tool.

Setting it up without extra work

Ahrefs users often worry this doubles the admin. It doesn't have to.

  • Log links as you build them, not afterwards. It takes a minute per link.
  • Import what you already have. If your built links live in a spreadsheet, import it once as CSV.
  • Let the checks run. In SEOENV, for example, every logged link is checked daily on paid plans (Starter+). On the Free plan, run Check all whenever you like.
  • Keep using Ahrefs for research and audits, exactly as before.

The Link Tracker holds the built links, and the Link Status Report gives a per-client view you can share.

When the two disagree

Sooner or later, your tracker will say a link is live and the index will say it's lost, or the other way round. When that happens, a direct look at the page settles it. If the link is on the page and correct, it exists. If it's gone, treat it as a real loss and follow up. Our guide to backlinks not showing in Ahrefs covers the crawler side, and why backlinks disappear covers real losses.

Frequently asked questions about Ahrefs users

Does Ahrefs track the links I built?

It shows links its crawler has found to a domain. It doesn't know which ones you built or what you agreed with each partner.

Why do Ahrefs users see links as lost when they're live?

Usually because the crawler hasn't revisited the page, or the site blocks AhrefsBot in robots.txt.

Should Ahrefs users switch to a link tracker?

No need to switch. After that, use Ahrefs for research and audits, and a tracker for the links you build.

Can SEOENV import links I found in Ahrefs?

Yes, if you export them to CSV. Import only the links you built, so your delivery numbers stay accurate.

Wrap-up and sources

Meanwhile, use these primary sources to check anything in this guide:

How we wrote this guide. Still, kritika Das wrote it from day-to-day work logging and checking link exchanges, guest posts and paid placements, and checked each claim against the sources above. We update it when Google changes its guidance.

What to keep in Ahrefs vs what to log in SEOENV

Leave broad competitor discovery, content gap ideas and organic research in Ahrefs. Log every link you built — guest posts, exchanges, paid placements, listings — in the Link Tracker with partner, project and promised anchor. That is how you answer “is our work still live?” without mixing it into a site-wide backlink profile.

For a fuller map of discovery tools versus managers, see backlink checkers vs managers and Google Sheets vs a backlink manager. This article stays on the weekly handoff.

Weekly handoff: from Ahrefs export to checked rows

Once a week, move new wins into SEOENV (manually or via CSV import), assign Partners and Projects, then run Check all or rely on automatic daily checks on Starter+. Use nofollow change detection when a live link flips attributes. Client-facing proof stays on a share link or monthly narrative from link building reports.

Track the links you built, alongside your index

SEOENV checks each logged link on its page and shows Active, Lost, Broken or Pending, for example, plus Dofollow or Nofollow.

Start free

Article written by

Kritika Das

Head of Marketing at SEOENV · Forbes-featured content writer

In addition, kritika Das is Head of Marketing at SEOENV and a Forbes-featured content writer. At the same time, she writes about the operations side of link building: how agencies, freelancers and in-house teams log, check and report the links they build. Her guides come from day-to-day work with link builders and are checked against Google’s own documentation.

More posts by Kritika